Skip to main content
All Guides
Metrics

GitHub Stats Are Broken. Build This Dashboard Instead

Go beyond GitHub Insights with team-level analytics. Learn what metrics matter, how to build a team dashboard, and how to turn GitHub stats into actionable insights.

12 min readUpdated December 25, 2025By CodePulse Team

GitHub's built-in Insights provide basic repository statistics, but they fall short for team-level visibility. This guide shows you how to compile meaningful GitHub statistics across your repositories—the numbers engineering managers actually need to track team performance.

Whether you're trying to understand team velocity, identify bottlenecks, or report to leadership, you need more than commit counts and contributor graphs. Here's how to build a proper statistics dashboard from your GitHub data.

What GitHub Insights Doesn't Show You

GitHub's native Insights are useful but limited:

GitHub Insights ShowsWhat Teams Actually Need
Commit count per contributorCycle time and throughput trends
Code frequency (additions/deletions)PR size distribution and risk analysis
Contributor listReview load balance and collaboration patterns
Traffic and clonesDelivery metrics (deployment frequency, lead time)
Per-repository data onlyCross-repository and org-level aggregation

The biggest gap: GitHub Insights are repository-centric, but teams work across multiple repositories. You need team-level aggregation.

Essential Team Dashboard Metrics

A proper team dashboard answers: How fast are we delivering? Are we delivering quality? Is the team sustainable? Here are the metrics that matter:

Delivery Speed

MetricDefinitionTarget
Cycle timeFirst commit to merge< 5 days
Time to first reviewPR opened to first review< 4 hours
Merge frequencyPRs merged per day/weekStable or trending up
PR throughputPRs completed per developerContext-dependent

Code Quality

MetricDefinitionTarget
Review coverage% of PRs with reviews100%
PR sizeLines changed per PR< 400 lines
Test failure rate% of PRs with failed checks< 10%
Code churn% of code rewritten within 2 weeks< 15%

Team Health

MetricDefinitionWarning Sign
Review load varianceDistribution of reviews across teamTop reviewer > 3x average
Knowledge silosFiles with single contributor> 20% of files
After-hours commitsWork outside business hours> 15% of commits
Stale PRsPRs open > 1 week> 10% of open PRs
See your engineering metrics in 5 minutes with CodePulse

Building Your Team Dashboard with CodePulse

CodePulse extracts these metrics from your GitHub data automatically. Here's how to set up an effective team dashboard:

Step 1: Connect Your Repositories

After connecting your GitHub organization, CodePulse syncs all repositories you have access to. You can then filter views by:

  • Specific repositories (for team-level view)
  • All repositories (for org-level view)
  • Time period (last 30 days, quarter, etc.)

Step 2: Review the Dashboard

The Dashboard shows your key metrics at a glance:

  • Cycle time breakdown: Where time is spent (coding, waiting, reviewing, merging)
  • PR activity: Opened, merged, and review trends
  • Quality indicators: Review coverage, test pass rates

Step 3: Explore Collaboration Patterns

The Review Network visualizes who reviews whose code:

  • Node size = review volume
  • Connections = review relationships
  • Isolated nodes = team members not participating in reviews

This helps identify overloaded reviewers, isolated contributors, and cross-team collaboration opportunities.

Step 4: Identify Code Risks

The File Hotspots view shows:

  • High-churn files that may need refactoring
  • Knowledge silos (single-contributor files)
  • Complex files getting frequent changes

Step 5: Set Up Alerts

Configure Alert Rules to catch problems early:

  • PRs waiting for review > 24 hours
  • Cycle time exceeding threshold
  • Review coverage dropping below 100%

Team-Level vs Org-Level Views

Different audiences need different views:

For Engineering Managers (Team View)

Focus on their specific repositories:

  • Filter dashboard to team's repos only
  • Track individual contributor patterns (for coaching, not evaluation)
  • Monitor sprint-to-sprint trends
  • Identify specific bottlenecks to address

For Directors/VPs (Org View)

Focus on cross-team patterns:

  • Compare metrics across teams (with context)
  • Identify organization-wide bottlenecks
  • Track quarter-over-quarter trends
  • Use Executive Summary for board reporting

⚠️ Comparing Teams Fairly

Team comparisons require context. A platform team's metrics will look different from a feature team's. Compare teams to their own baselines, not to each other, unless they're doing similar work.

Common GitHub Stats Questions

"What's our team velocity?"

Look at PRs merged per week, trending over time. But remember:

  • Velocity isn't a target—it's a planning tool
  • Sustainable velocity > maximum velocity
  • Quality metrics should accompany velocity metrics

"Who are our bottlenecks?"

Check the cycle time breakdown:

  • Long "wait for review" = need more reviewers or SLAs
  • Long "review time" = PRs too large or complex
  • Long "merge time" = approval/CI process issues

Also check the Review Network for overloaded reviewers.

"Are we improving?"

Compare metrics month-over-month:

  • Cycle time trending down = good
  • Review coverage stable at 100% = good
  • PR size trending down = good
  • After-hours commits trending down = good

"What should we focus on?"

Start with the biggest bottleneck in your cycle time breakdown. Typical priority:

  1. Review wait time (if > 4 hours average)
  2. PR size (if > 400 lines average)
  3. Knowledge silos (if > 20% siloed files)
  4. Test failure rate (if > 10%)

From GitHub Stats to Actionable Insights

The goal isn't just to collect stats—it's to drive improvement. Here's how to turn data into action:

Weekly Team Check-In

  1. Review dashboard metrics (5 minutes)
  2. Discuss any alerts that fired
  3. Identify one thing to improve this week
  4. Check progress on previous week's focus

Monthly Leadership Report

  1. Export key metrics from the Dashboard
  2. Add context (what happened, why metrics moved)
  3. Highlight wins and areas of concern
  4. Propose actions for next month

Quarterly Planning

  1. Review quarter-over-quarter trends
  2. Identify systemic issues to address
  3. Set improvement goals with specific metrics
  4. Allocate time for process improvements

Getting Started

Ready to build your team dashboard? Here's the quick start:

  1. Connect GitHub – Authorize CodePulse for your organization
  2. Wait for sync – Initial data processing takes 30-60 minutes
  3. Review Dashboard – See your current cycle time and throughput
  4. Check Review Network – Understand collaboration patterns
  5. Set up alerts – Get notified when PRs get stuck

Within a day, you'll have visibility that GitHub Insights alone can't provide.

See these insights for your team

CodePulse connects to your GitHub and shows you actionable engineering metrics in minutes. No complex setup required.

Free tier available. No credit card required.